If you’ve come across a 2011-P James Garfield Dollar coin, you’re probably wondering whether it’s worth holding onto — or cashing in. The good news is that this coin is worth anywhere from face value ($1) in circulated condition to $5–$15 or more in uncirculated mint state, with rare high-grade examples fetching even higher prices at auction.
What Is the 2011-P James Garfield Dollar Coin?
The 2011-P James Garfield Dollar is part of the Presidential Dollar series, a program launched by the U.S. Mint in 2007 to honor former U.S. presidents on circulating dollar coins. James Garfield, the 20th President of the United States, was featured in the fourth and final release of 2011.
The “P” in the coin’s name stands for the Philadelphia Mint, where it was struck. These coins were produced in large quantities — around 37.1 million pieces — which is one reason why most circulated examples aren’t worth much more than a dollar.
That said, coins in pristine, uncirculated condition — especially those graded MS65 or higher by professional services like PCGS or NGC — can be worth considerably more to collectors. If you’re not sure what grade your coin might be, a free coin identifier app can help you get a quick read on your coin’s condition and approximate value without needing to visit a dealer right away.
How Much Is the 2011-P Garfield Dollar Worth?
Value depends heavily on condition. A coin that’s been circulating in pockets and registers will show wear, reducing its collector appeal. Meanwhile, an uncirculated coin that has never been used as currency — especially one stored carefully since it left the mint — can command a real premium.
Here’s a general value breakdown for the 2011-P James Garfield Dollar:
| Condition | Grade | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| Circulated (worn) | VF–EF | $1.00 – $1.50 |
| Uncirculated | MS63–MS64 | $2.00 – $5.00 |
| Gem Uncirculated | MS65 | $5.00 – $12.00 |
| Superb Gem | MS66–MS67 | $15.00 – $50.00+ |
| Proof (San Francisco) | PR69–PR70 | $8.00 – $30.00 |
For live market pricing, you can check the latest 2011-P dollar coin price data and recent sales trends to see what collectors are actually paying right now.
Key Features to Look For on Your 2011-P Garfield Dollar
Before assuming your coin is just worth a dollar, take a closer look. There are a few things that can significantly affect its value.
Edge lettering errors are among the most exciting finds. Presidential Dollars have the date, mint mark, and motto “IN GOD WE TRUST” inscribed on the edge. Some coins were released with missing or doubled edge lettering — these error coins can be worth $50 to $200 or more depending on the severity of the mistake.
Strike quality also matters. Coins with sharp, well-defined details on Garfield’s portrait and clean fields (the flat areas around the design) are more desirable to collectors. You can use CoinHix to photograph your coin and instantly compare it against graded examples to estimate where it might fall on the scale.
Look for coins that still have their original mint luster — that subtle shine you see on a brand-new coin. Once that luster is gone, the value drops sharply for collectors.
The 2011-P Garfield Dollar in Sets and Rolls
Many people hold onto Presidential Dollars as part of a complete set. Completing all four 2011 Presidential Dollar coins — Lincoln, Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, and James Garfield — in high grades can be a satisfying and modestly valuable collection.
Original mint-sealed rolls and bags of 2011-P Garfield Dollars are also collected. A 25-coin roll in original bank-wrapped condition can sell for $15–$30, mostly because collectors trust the coins inside haven’t been touched or sorted through.
If you have a full roll or a set and want to understand its total value, checking a detailed breakdown of 2011 dollar coin values by grade and mint mark can help you price your collection more accurately.
CoinHix is especially handy here — just scan a few coins from your roll and get an instant estimate without needing to count them one by one.
Should You Get It Graded?
Professional grading by PCGS or NGC is really only worth the cost if your coin appears to be MS66 or higher, or if you have a suspected error coin. Grading fees typically start around $20–$30 per coin, so spending that on a common $2 coin doesn’t make financial sense.
However, if your 2011-P Garfield Dollar has an obvious error — missing edge lettering, a doubled die, or an off-center strike — it’s absolutely worth getting a professional opinion. CoinHix can be a great first step before you commit to paying for third-party grading, giving you a sense of whether your coin is truly special.
—
FAQ About the 2011-P James Garfield Dollar Coin
Q: Is the 2011-P James Garfield Dollar rare?
A: No, it’s not considered rare. With over 37 million minted at Philadelphia alone, these coins are widely available. However, high-grade examples (MS66 and above) and error coins are genuinely scarce and worth seeking out.
Q: What makes a 2011-P Garfield Dollar worth more than face value?
A: Condition is the biggest factor. Uncirculated coins, especially those graded MS65 or higher, command premiums among collectors. Error coins — particularly those with missing edge lettering — can be worth many times their face value.
Q: Where can I sell my 2011-P James Garfield Dollar coin?
A: You can sell on platforms like eBay, through local coin dealers, or at coin shows. For a quick valuation before you sell, apps like CoinHix can give you a realistic sense of what your coin is worth so you don’t leave money on the table.
